Beyond AI Competence: Ethical-Pedagogical Agency in Primary Islamic Education
Kata Kunci:
ethical-pedagogical agency, generative artificial intelligence, teacher professional learning, Islamic education, teacher agencyAbstrak
The growing use of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) in education has intensified questions about teacher competence, ethical responsibility, and professional learning. This conceptual paper develops a provisional account of ethical-pedagogical agency for primary Islamic education. It asks how teachers mobilise professional resources when evaluating AI-generated material, how professional learning may support the revision of judgment, and how contextual conditions shape the enactment of decisions. The paper uses a critical conceptual synthesis of scholarship on teacher agency, AI competence, professional learning, AI ethics, and Islamic education. Rather than claiming to conduct a systematic review, it compares the explanatory focus of selected frameworks and uses that comparison to develop a conceptual model. The analysis distinguishes professional resources from situated professional judgment and from the enactment of decisions. Ethical-pedagogical agency is specified through four provisional dimensions: epistemic discernment, ethical deliberation, context-sensitive pedagogical judgment, and accountable professional justification. Professional learning is treated as a potential developmental process rather than an automatic cause of agency, while epistemic, pedagogical, ethical, and institutional conditions are proposed as boundary conditions. The paper contributes a set of theoretical propositions that can guide empirical investigation and professional development. The model is not empirically validated; further studies are needed to assess its conceptual distinctiveness, practical observability, and explanatory value across varied primary Islamic education settings.
