Negotiating Religious Knowledge with Generative AI: Epistemic Authority and Tabayyun Practices among Islamic Education Postgraduate Students
Kata Kunci:
generative AI, epistemic authority, tabayyun, Islamic education, postgraduate studentsAbstrak
The growing use of generative artificial intelligence (AI) in higher education has transformed how students access, interpret, and validate knowledge, including religious knowledge. This transformation raises an epistemological concern in Islamic education because fluent AI-generated responses do not necessarily possess scholarly or religious authority. This study investigates how postgraduate students in Islamic education negotiate the epistemic authority of generative AI when accessing religious knowledge and how their verification practices reflect the Islamic principle of tabayyun. Employing a qualitative exploratory design, data were collected through semi-structured written interviews with six postgraduate students in Islamic education who had experience using generative AI for academic purposes. The data were analyzed thematically to identify patterns of AI use, verification, and trust in religious sources. The findings reveal three interrelated patterns. First, participants primarily position AI as an initial informational and academic assistant rather than a final source of religious authority. Second, AI-generated religious information is subjected to verification through books, Islamic texts, lecturers, kiai, religiously knowledgeable individuals, and other relevant sources. Third, when AI-generated information conflicts with established religious sources or human scholarly authority, participants tend to prioritize scholars and authoritative texts. These findings indicate that tabayyun operates as an epistemic practice through which students negotiate technological convenience without transferring religious authority entirely to algorithms. The study concludes that Islamic higher education should cultivate critical AI literacy that integrates technological competence with verification, scholarly authority, and epistemic responsibility.
