Rethinking Critical Thinking Student From AI Assistance to Cognitive Offloading in Elementary School
Keywords:
generative AI, cognitive offloading, critical thinking, Madrasah Ibtidaiyah, teachers’ pedagogical roleAbstract
The development of generative AI (GenAI) makes it easier for students to access information and complete assignments, but it raises concerns that the thinking process is being shifted to technology, especially among elementary school-aged children. Previous studies have primarily focused on the benefits, readiness for adoption, and instructional design, while empirical evidence regarding cognitive offloading in Madrasah Ibtidaiyah remains limited. This study aims to identify patterns of GenAI use as a learning aid, examine the shift toward cognitive offloading, analyze its implications for students’ critical thinking processes, and examine the pedagogical role of teachers. This qualitative field study was conducted at MI Salafiyah Kertoharjo with 10 fourth-grade students and one classroom teacher as participants. Data were collected through observation, student interviews, and teacher interviews, then analyzed using the Miles, Huberman, and Saldaña interactive model, accompanied by source triangulation. The results show that students primarily use GenAI for homework assignments such as poems and questions, usually with help from family members, because the tasks feel difficult, they want to finish quickly, and they are reluctant to read. AI outputs are copied without being processed, so some students cannot explain their work and have difficulty completing similar assignments independently in class. Teachers conduct checks, provide guidance, offer explanations, and offer support, but still find it difficult to distinguish independent work from AI-generated results. The study concludes that GenAI shifts from being a tool to partially replacing the thinking process when not accompanied by cognitive engagement and pedagogical guidance. This study provides triangulated evidence from Islamic elementary education and recommends process-based assignments, verification exercises, strengthening teachers’ digital literacy, and parental involvement
