From Algorithms to Adab: A Bibliometric Analysis of AI-Driven Adaptive Learning Research and Its Implications for Islamic Education
Keywords:
adaptive learning, artificial intelligence, bibliometric analysis, generative AI, Islamic educationAbstract
AI-driven adaptive learning is expanding rapidly, yet little is known about how its research agenda has shifted since the rise of generative AI or what this shift means for Islamic education. This bibliometric study analysed 2,818 Scopus documents (2010–2027) through VOSviewer co-occurrence mapping of 1,000 keywords. Publications rose from 7 in 2010 to 1,064 in 2025, and 91% of the corpus appeared from 2023 onward. Eleven clusters formed three layers: a human-centred core of ethics, data mining, classroom implementation and generative AI (48.5% of keywords), adaptive-system architecture (21.4%), and application domains (30.1%). Overlay mapping showed a shift from adaptive systems and data mining toward large language models, data privacy and ethics. None of the mapped keywords addressed Islamic education. We argue that the concept of adab offers a framework for the ethical and epistemological questions now central to the field and propose a research agenda for madrasah and pesantren.
