The Use of Artificial Intelligence in Death Penalty Decision-Making: An Analysis Based on Islamic Ethics and Maqāṣid al-Sharīʿah
Keywords:
artificial intelligence, death penalty, islamic ethics, maqāṣid al-sharīʿah, human oversightAbstract
The increasing use of artificial intelligence (AI) in criminal justice and sentencing raises significant ethical concerns, particularly when algorithmic systems are applied to decisions involving the deprivation of human life. While AI may enhance efficiency, consistency, and access to legal information, its use in capital sentencing presents risks related to inaccurate data, algorithmic bias, opacity, automation bias, limited explainability, and the displacement of human responsibility. This study aims to examine the ethical implications of using AI in determining the death penalty from the perspectives of Islamic ethics and maqāṣid al-sharīʿah, and to develop a normative framework for responsible AI-assisted sentencing. The study adopts a doctrinal, normative, and conceptual research design based on qualitative analysis of primary Islamic sources, scholarly literature, legal and policy documents, and contemporary AI governance frameworks. The findings indicate that the use of AI in capital sentencing must be constrained by the principles of ʿadl (justice), tabayyun (verification), amānah (trust and responsibility), masʾūliyyah (accountability), karāmah al-insān (human dignity), ḥifẓ al-nafs (protection of life), and dafʿ al-ḍarar (prevention of harm). The study proposes the Islamic AI Death Penalty Decision Framework (IADPDF), comprising six layers: purpose, data integrity, algorithmic fairness, explainability and transparency, meaningful human oversight, and maqāṣid assessment. The study concludes that AI should function only as a decision-support instrument, while the final determination of capital punishment must remain with human judges. Accordingly, a presumption against AI-driven capital sentencing is proposed.
