From Penghulu to Algorithms? Reconfiguring the Authority of Islamic Marriage-Law Consultation in Indonesia in the Era of Artificial Intelligence
Keywords:
artificial intelligence, marriage officiant (Penghulu), algorithmic authority, maqāṣid al-syarī‘ah, gender justiceAbstract
The development of artificial intelligence (AI) is transforming how religious knowledge and family law are produced, accessed, and validated. In Indonesia, AI-based chatbots can be used to obtain information on marriage requirements, guardians, dowry, alimony, divorce, child custody, and other family matters. These developments raise questions regarding the role of the penghulu as an institutional and religious authority in consultations on Islamic marriage law. This study aims to analyze the construction of the penghulu’s authority, the characteristics of algorithmic authority in AI responses, and a model of the relationship between AI and the penghulu that aligns with the maqāṣid al-syarī‘ah and gender justice. The study employs a conceptual socio-legal approach based on document analysis and AI responses. The analyzed documents include marriage regulations, regulations regarding the office of the penghulu, the Compilation of Islamic Law, data protection policies, literature on Islamic family law, as well as studies on AI and digital religious authority. AI responses were collected through hypothetical and anonymous scenarios regarding marriage law issues, then analyzed based on normative accuracy, clarity of sources, contextuality, protection of vulnerable parties, gender justice, and mechanisms for referral to human authorities. The results of the analysis show that the authority of marriage officiant (Penghulu) s is multidimensional, encompassing legal-institutional, religious, social, and ethical-consultative dimensions. In contrast, AI’s authority is functional and epistemic, shaped by speed, accessibility, anonymity, personalization, and persuasive language. However, AI lacks religious authority, moral responsibility, a deep understanding of context, and institutional accountability. This study argues that AI does not replace the marriage officiant (Penghulu) but rather reconfigures the authority of marriage law consultation. The novelty of this research lies in a model of AI-assisted marriage law consultation under the supervision of a marriage officiant (Penghulu), which integrates institutional authority, algorithmic authority, maqāṣid al-syarī‘ah, gender justice, and human accountability.
